Love Island USA Season 5 Winners Marco Donatelli and Hannah Wright Are Engaged

Hannah, 25, also toasted to their future in the comments section, proudly declaring that she’s now “Mrs. Donatelli.” 

And while she’s excited about the next level of their relationship, the reality star wasn’t expecting to leave the resort town with an engagement ring.

“I was shocked,” she told People in a May 30 interview. “I had no idea. I was convinced that we were solely there for a vacation trip. I was crying the whole time the setup was beautiful and felt like a dream.”

Meanwhile, Marco had this special moment on his mind for quite some time. After “nine months” of planning, which included designing her solitaire cut diamond ring, he finalized the details last December. In fact, he noted that fine tuning the diamond to perfection was a “long process,” but he knew the preparation would be worth it.